A 523: etext transcription
- Physical Description
- Manuscript: A 523
- Date: [last decade (THJ)]
- Status: fragment, extrageneric
- Formula: 1 fragment
- Paper: law book, leaf
- Dimensions: 56 x 72 mm
- Edges: bottom, left, right: torn; reverse: top, left, right: torn
- Media: pencil
- Hand: rough
- Collection
- Amherst College Library
- Transmission History
- MSS from LND to MLT, 1891?
- Publication History
- NEQ 28 (September 1955): 316; Letters (1958), PF 123, PF 121, respectively
- Commentary
-
One of the many brief extrageneric texts found among her late papers after her death, Dickinson's final intentions toward this fragment remain unknown. It may have been destined for incorporation into a poem, a letter, or another composition; alternatively, it may be an experiment in aphoristic form; or, possibly, a compressed lyric poem unrecognized as such because of the crudeness of its material container. Though the relationship between the texts on the opposite sides of the manuscript is unclear, both are composed in the same hand and the lines on A 523 rhyme with the lines on the A 523a. The lines on A 523a may complete the text on A 523, or, since the reverse side of a manuscript often appears to be a scene of revision, they may be variants for lines on A 523. One word on A 523a, here uncertainly transcribed as "Below," may read "Beloved"; it is composed sideways along the left edge of the paper and is partially lost beyond the tear. This single word may belong to an earlier text, lost beyond the tear, or to the present text, with which it also rhymes. For a different interpretation of textual boundaries, see T. H. Johnson, Letters (1958), PF 123, PF 121, respectively.
-
- Tags
- Text was composed between c.1870 and c.1886
- Document was discovered among Dickinson's papers, unbound
- Law book, leaf
- Document has been torn; text has been lost beyond the tears
- Composed by Dickinson in pencil
- Composed by Dickinson in a rough-copy hand
- Dickinson's writing appears on both sides of the paper/leaf
- Dickinson's writing appears sideways along the left and/or right edges of the paper
- Dickinson rotated the paper during the course of the composition of a discrete text
- Dickinson composed her text around, over, or on the verso of a printed text
- Text contains additions or variants
- Text contains illegible letters, words, and/or passages
- Amherst College Library, Special Collections